The Ontario Court of Appeal has provided important guidance for employers whose compensation packages include restricted stock units, bonuses, equity awards, or other forms of incentive compensation. In the wrongful dismissal case Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., the Court considered both the enforceability of an employment agreement’s termination provisions and whether an employee was entitled to millions of dollars in restricted stock units that would have vested during the reasonable notice period.

The decision illustrates how the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) can affect more than an employee’s base salary and benefits at termination. It also highlights the importance of reviewing employment agreements, equity plans, and related compensation documents together.

The Employee’s Compensation Included Significant RSUs

The employee was a senior technology professional whose business had been acquired by the employer’s parent company. As part of the transaction, the employee joined the employer and received a substantial compensation package.

Among other things, the employee was granted 43,380 restricted stock units (RSUs), initially valued at US$7.5 million. The RSUs vested according to a four-year schedule and became common shares once vested. The employee’s initial base salary was $232,000, later increasing to approximately $253,100.

The RSUs were governed by an equity incentive plan and separate RSU agreements. However, the documentation concerning the RSUs was incorporated into the employee’s employment agreement. The Court also noted that the employer characterized RSU grants as an element of employee compensation intended both to compensate employees for continued service and encourage retention.

The Employment Agreement’s Termination Clause Became a Central Issue

The employee had worked for his previous company for approximately nine years before becoming employed by the purchaser. Under section 9 of the ESA, where an employer sells a business and the purchaser continues to employ an employee, the employee’s prior service can be relevant when calculating subsequent ESA termination entitlements.

The employment agreement nevertheless contemplated that, during the employee’s first three months with the purchaser, his employment could be terminated on two weeks’ advance notice or base pay in lieu. The lower court concluded that this provision failed to recognize the ESA entitlements arising from the employee’s prior service. The Court of Appeal upheld that conclusion.

The result was significant. Because the termination provisions contravened ESA minimum standards, they were unenforceable and did not displace the employee’s common law entitlement to reasonable notice. The employee was therefore entitled to damages based on a 10-month common law notice period.

General ESA Compliance Language Did Not Save the Clause

The employment agreement contained broader language stating that the employee would never receive less than his minimum statutory entitlements. The employer argued that the agreement should be interpreted as a whole and that these provisions demonstrated an intention to comply with the ESA.

The Court nevertheless upheld the finding that the specific termination provision was unlawful. A general statement promising ESA compliance could not cure a provision that expressly contemplated entitlements below statutory minimums.

The Court reiterated that the enforceability of a termination clause is determined from its wording. An employer’s actual compliance with the ESA when employment eventually ends does not repair contractual language that failed to comply with the statute when the agreement was entered into.

Sophistication and Legal Advice Did Not Change the Analysis

Another noteworthy aspect of the decision involved the employee’s sophistication. The employee had legal representation during the transaction that resulted in the sale of his business and the negotiation of his employment arrangements.

The Court rejected the suggestion that an employee who had received legal advice should be entitled to less contractual clarity than another employee. It observed that an employee’s sophistication or access to independent advice cannot override the language contained in a termination provision.

For employers, this aspect of the decision reinforces the importance of the contractual wording itself. Negotiation, seniority, sophistication, or independent legal representation do not necessarily protect an otherwise non-compliant termination provision.

What Happens to RSUs During an ESA Notice Period?

The principal issue on the employee’s appeal involved RSUs that would have vested after his employment ended. Section 60 of the ESA provides that, during the statutory notice period, an employer cannot reduce an employee’s wage rate or alter another term or condition of employment. Section 61 permits an employer to provide pay instead of working notice, but the amount must equal what the employee would have been entitled to receive had notice been provided under section 60.

The Court concluded that the two provisions must be read together. Pay in lieu of notice must be calculated on the basis that the employee’s terms and conditions of employment remain unaltered throughout the statutory notice period. The purpose is to place employees in the same financial position whether they receive working notice or compensation instead of notice.

Importantly, the Court interpreted the statutory language as extending beyond regular wages. The amount payable can include compensation the employee would have received had employment continued throughout the statutory notice period.

The RSU Forfeiture Provisions Contravened the ESA

The RSU agreements stated, in different formulations, that unvested RSUs would cease vesting when employment terminated. One version expressly prevented continued vesting during the statutory notice period. Later versions contained language stating that vesting stopped unless applicable legislation explicitly required otherwise.

The Court concluded that these provisions were inconsistent with the ESA. Because the RSUs formed part of the employee’s terms and conditions of employment, terminating their vesting during the statutory notice period would alter those terms and conditions contrary to section 60.

The later agreements’ saving language did not change the result. The ESA does not expressly refer to RSUs, so language preserving vesting only where legislation “explicitly” required it was insufficient. Any ambiguity was also to be interpreted in favour of the employee.

The Consequence Extended Beyond the Statutory Notice Period

The financial consequence was substantial. Had the employee remained employed during his 10-month reasonable notice period, RSUs worth approximately US$4.71 million would have vested.

Because the RSU termination provisions contravened the ESA, they were void and could not effectively remove the employee’s common law entitlement to compensation for the RSUs during the reasonable notice period. The Court therefore increased the damages award by US$4,711,647.29.

This distinction is particularly important for employers. A contractual provision that fails to preserve an employee’s minimum ESA entitlements can have consequences extending considerably beyond the minimum statutory notice period if the provision is consequently incapable of limiting common law damages.

Punitive Damages Were Not Awarded

The employee also sought punitive damages because his statutory termination payments were not made until approximately 10 months after his termination and after legal proceedings had commenced. The employer attributed the delay to an administrative oversight.

The lower court found that the circumstances suggested more than an innocent administrative error, but did not amount to sufficiently harsh, malicious, or reprehensible conduct to justify punitive damages. The Court of Appeal found no basis to interfere with that conclusion. The delay illustrates why the timing of statutory termination payments matters when employers prepare severance packages.

Facebook Canada and Meta applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. As of November 15, 2026, the Court’s docket showed the application was pending.

Grosman Gale Fletcher Hopkins LLP: Toronto Employment Lawyers for Equity Compensation and Termination

The Toronto employment lawyers at Grosman Gale Fletcher Hopkins LLP advise employers across Ontario on employment agreements, equity compensation plans, and termination obligations. The firm helps employers review how restricted stock units and other incentives are treated on termination, assess severance exposure, and respond to wrongful dismissal claims.

To schedule a confidential consultation, call 416-364-9599 or contact the firm online.